Editing User:Aaronshaw/Better Wikipedia citations
From CommunityData
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision | Your text | ||
Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
Let's say I want to cite the article on the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seneca_Falls_Convention Seneca Falls Convention]. Here's a screenshot of that article taken in February, 2020. | Let's say I want to cite the article on the [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seneca_Falls_Convention Seneca Falls Convention]. Here's a screenshot of that article taken in February, 2020. | ||
[[File:Seneca_falls_convention-20200212.png|thumb| | [[File:Seneca_falls_convention-20200212.png|thumb|right|1. The page I want to cite in this example. Click to see a bigger version of the image and notice the "View history" link near the top right corner of the article text.]] | ||
=== 1. View history for the page you want === | === 1. View history for the page you want === | ||
Line 25: | Line 25: | ||
Now you should be looking at something called a "revision history" for the original page. There's a bunch of stuff, but the main thing we're interested in is the list of things going down the middle of the page. Each of the items in this list is a previous revision of the article you were looking at a moment ago. Each row corresponds to one revision and includes some useful information such as the timestamp for when the edit was saved, the username of the editor who saved it (if applicable), the length of the article in bytes after the revision (and the length of the revision in parentheses), as well as any edit summary text that the editor entered at the time they saved the revision. | Now you should be looking at something called a "revision history" for the original page. There's a bunch of stuff, but the main thing we're interested in is the list of things going down the middle of the page. Each of the items in this list is a previous revision of the article you were looking at a moment ago. Each row corresponds to one revision and includes some useful information such as the timestamp for when the edit was saved, the username of the editor who saved it (if applicable), the length of the article in bytes after the revision (and the length of the revision in parentheses), as well as any edit summary text that the editor entered at the time they saved the revision. | ||
[[File:Seneca_falls_convention_viewhistory-20200212.png|thumb| | [[File:Seneca_falls_convention_viewhistory-20200212.png|thumb|right|2. What you see after you click "View history". Notice that the previous revisions are organized in reverse-chronological order. Also notice that each revision has a timestamp associated with it (a column near the left) and that you can click on any of the timestamps to view the revision in question.]] | ||
Assuming the page looked okay to you when you clicked "View history" a moment ago, the version you want is the most recent one right at the top of the list (the revisions are organized in reverse chronological order by default). Go ahead and click the timestamp for this revision. | Assuming the page looked okay to you when you clicked "View history" a moment ago, the version you want is the most recent one right at the top of the list (the revisions are organized in reverse chronological order by default). Go ahead and click the timestamp for this revision. | ||
Line 34: | Line 34: | ||
At this point, you should be looking at the article again. Indeed, if you clicked the most recent revision from the list, you are looking at ''exactly the same version'' of the article you had seen before. So what's changed? Well, for starters, the address (URL) of the page. Look at the end of it closely. It should end in "&oldid=XXXXXXXX" where the X's correspond to some numbers. This means that the address points to the specific version of the article you clicked on from the revision list. The number is called a "revision ID" and each revision ID is, in theory, unique (database errors happen, but let's just assume that's not the case because it would be a bigger issue if they started duplicating such IDs on Wikipedia...). The other difference is the little yellow box of text across the top of the page that basically explains that the address is a permanent link. | At this point, you should be looking at the article again. Indeed, if you clicked the most recent revision from the list, you are looking at ''exactly the same version'' of the article you had seen before. So what's changed? Well, for starters, the address (URL) of the page. Look at the end of it closely. It should end in "&oldid=XXXXXXXX" where the X's correspond to some numbers. This means that the address points to the specific version of the article you clicked on from the revision list. The number is called a "revision ID" and each revision ID is, in theory, unique (database errors happen, but let's just assume that's not the case because it would be a bigger issue if they started duplicating such IDs on Wikipedia...). The other difference is the little yellow box of text across the top of the page that basically explains that the address is a permanent link. | ||
[[File:Seneca_falls_convention_oldid-20200212.png|thumb| | [[File:Seneca_falls_convention_oldid-20200212.png|thumb|right|3. A specific revision from the history of the page I was looking at originally. Notice that the URL (address) for the page contains the text "&oldid=XXXXXXXX" where the X's correspond to some numbers. Also notice that the yellow textbox across the top of the page indicates (not quite accurately?) that the address (URL) "provides a permanent link to this version."]] | ||
Now, finally, you have a link you can trust to point to the version of the page that is exactly as you saw it when you visited. | Now, finally, you have a link you can trust to point to the version of the page that is exactly as you saw it when you visited. You can go ahead and cite this URL using your preferred citation method. If your instructor, students, audience, or readers wonder why, just send them to read this page. | ||