Editing Online Communities and Crowds (Winter 2022)

<div style="float:right;" width=30%; class="toclimit-3">__TOC__</div>

;Online Communities & Crowds
:Communication Studies 378 (undergraduate)
:Media, Technology & Society (MTS) 525 (graduate)
:Wednesdays 10am-11:30am CT
:: (in-person) Frances Searle Building, Room 2-407
:: (remote) See below for Zoom details
:Winter, 2022
:Northwestern University

;Course websites
: [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351 Canvas] for announcements, submitting assignments, and file sharing.
: [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com Panopto] for recorded, asynchronous lectures.
: [https://northwestern.zoom.us/j/94062167477 Zoom] for remote, synchronous course meetings and guest speaker visits.
: [https://discord.com Class discord server] (invite available via Canvas or instructors) for chat, lightweight Q&A, etc..
: [https://dashboard.wikiedu.org/courses/Northwestern_University/Online_communities_and_crowds_(Winter)/home Wikipedia Assignment dashboard] for everything related to the Wikipedia Assignment.
: Undergraduate (Comm Studies 378) discussion section is held Fridays at 2-107. Details can be found on the [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Undergraduate_sections|Undergraduate sections page]].
: Graduate (MTS 525) discussion section details can be found on the [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Graduate_section|Graduate section page]].
: [https://wiki.communitydata.science/Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022) This wiki page] for nearly everything else.

;'''Instructor:''' [http://aaronshaw.org Aaron Shaw] ([mailto:aaronshaw@northwestern.edu aaronshaw@northwestern.edu])
:Office Hours: Wednesdays 12:30-2:30pm and by-appointment.
:[[User:Aaronshaw/OH|Location and details]].
:Please [[User:Aaronshaw/OH|signup if you'd like an appointment]] or drop-in if a slot is listed as available.
:Also usually available via Discord for chat during "business hours."

;'''Teaching Assistant:''' [https://sohyeonhwang.com/ Sohyeon Hwang] [mailto:sohyeonhwang@u.northwestern.edu sohyeonhwang@u.northwestern.edu]
:Office Hours: 
::(remote for entire quarter, please [https://wiki.communitydata.science/User:Sohw#Office_hours read info on this linked page and sign up]) Mondays 12:30-1:30PM CT, virtually at: [[https://meet.jit.si/sohw]] (password on the prior linked page)
::(once in-person is safe again, just drop-in) Tuesdays 11AM-1PM CT, at room 2-430 in Frances Searle (up the main stairs from the lobby, and then go right).
:Also usually available via Discord for chat during "business hours".

<div class="res-box">
[[File:Occ-ai.jpg|thumb|275px|Detail of an ukiyo-e styled image generated by Wombo.ai from the prompt "online communities and crowds" on December 27, 2021]]
</div>

== Course information ==
=== Overview ===

Online communities & crowds are fundamental to how people communicate, work, play, learn, socialize, and more. However, they also threaten our well-being and undermine critical social institutions as well as the integrity of public discourse. 

This course seeks to understand online communities & crowds. It does so through an interdisciplinary inquiry into a set of practical challenges that confront online communities & crowds today. When and why do some efforts to overcome these challenges succeed? What insights and expectations can we draw from these experiences? 

==== Learning objectives ====

The course is designed to enable students to achieve the following goals:
* Understand and critically engage central concepts, examples, and issues relevant to online communities & crowds.
* Cultivate practical experience with online collaboration (in online communities and crowds).
* Assess and iteratively improve upon your own work and that of your peers in light of the concerns analyzed in class.
* Elaborate original insights into online communities & crowds; extend and apply the material presented in class.

=== Format and materials ===

As of December 20, 2021, Northwestern University has required that all classes proceed via remote instruction for the first two weeks of Winter Quarter, 2022. The hybrid format of our course is designed to be robust to this change. At this time, all synchronous remote sessions will all be held via Zoom (details and links to-be-distributed via Canvas). If/when possible, we will hold in-person synchronous sessions on campus.

The course consists of both synchronous (remote or in-person) and asynchronous (recorded) lecture sessions as well as synchronous (remote or in-person) discussion sections. The undergraduate discussion sections will be led by the Teaching Assistant and the graduate discussion section will be led by the Instructor.

The lectures will synthesize a variety of historical, theoretical, and empirical materials. The discussion sections will focus on weekly reading/viewing assignments.

All readings and other materials for the course will be linked from this page and/or posted on Canvas.

=== Assignments and responsibilities ===

The course includes "weekly" and "irregular" assignments.

Every week all participants are responsible for (1) consuming any recorded lecture(s); (2) attending the synchronous lecture and discussion section; and (3) completing any weekly assignments. Weekly assignments are usually readings along with reading quizzes (undergraduate) or memos (graduate). The graduate reading assignments usually consist of the undergraduate reading assignments ''plus additional materials'' (the schedule indicates this accordingly). 

Everyone in the course will complete the Wikipedia assignment. Otherwise, the irregular assignments for graduate and undergraduate members of the course diverge quite a bit. Details are provided below.

All written assignments should be submitted as a PDF via Canvas. I recommend you familiarize yourself with Aaron's [[User:Aaronshaw/Assessment|assessment policies]] (especially the assessment rubric for written work) as well as salient [[User:Aaronshaw/Classroom_policies#Academic_integrity|principles on academic integrity]], especially the appropriate attribution of sources. Please submit written work in a readable (size 11 or greater) font and adopt a standard citation style (e.g., APA or PACM HCI) throughout. Please include your name somewhere (prominent!) in the document that you submit as well as your last name at the beginning of the filename (e.g., "Shaw-occ-week1-assignment.pdf").

==== Weekly assignments ====

The course schedule provides details of all reading assignments as well as links to materials and Canvas pages for submitting written assignments. Specifics for several types of assignments follow below.

===== Undergraduate: Reading quizzes =====

At the beginning of every Wednesday class session (with the exceptions of Weeks 1 and 10), all members of the undergraduate course will receive a reading quiz via Canvas. The reading quiz will consist of a small number of multiple-choice questions, which will be graded out of 10 points. The quiz will start when class starts and end four minutes later. If you are slightly late starting the quiz, you might be able to complete it in time. If you are very late or absent, you’ll get a zero. There are no make-up quizzes. At the end of the term, we’ll drop your lowest three quiz grades.

===== Graduate: Discussion memos and lead discussants =====

Graduate students in the course are required to submit discussion memos via Canvas no later than Tuesday at 9pm CT each week (with the exception of week 1). The memos are intended to facilitate digestion of the reading/viewing materials ahead of each discussion section. They should be short (400-500 words) and should synthesize central arguments and/or themes of readings/viewings. During the quarter you may skip up to two discussion memos with no consequences. 

Each graduate student will also be required to serve as a lead discussant in section at least once during the quarter. Details and expectations will be discussed in the first section meeting.

==== Irregular assignments ==== 

Irregular assignments include the Wikipedia assignment as well as several longer-form written assignments. Brief descriptions follow here with additional details provided via linked pages.

===== The Wikipedia assignment (everyone): =====

All members of the course will participate in the collaborative creation of ''de novo'' Wikipedia articles. This assignment will proceed in small teams of 4-5 people led by graduate students and will take place over about six weeks starting at the beginning of the quarter. It will culminate in a short essay reflecting on and assessing the experience in light of the other course materials. 

Please review [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Wikipedia_assignment|this overview of the assignment and assessment criteria]]. Details of specific assignment milestones and deadlines will be (almost entirely) provided through the course WikiEdu Dashboard.

;Deadlines (See WikiEdu Dashboard for specific assignments and most up-to-date/accurate deadlines):
:January 8: Introduction, Create an account, join the course page, learn some basics, evaluate an article
:January 14: Review some more rules, Start working with your team, Choose possible article topics
:January 21: Edit existing articles/citations, finalize article topic, start drafting articles
:January 28: Exchange and respond to peer review of article drafts
:February 4: Improve/polish articles, publish articles (move them into the main namespace)
:February 11: Final revisions to articles before reflective essay.
:February 18: Reflection essay due.

===== Undergraduate =====
====== Exam ======

Undergraduate students in the course will be required to complete a take-home exam late in the quarter that will cover material from lectures and from the assigned readings. The exam will consist of several short essay prompts. The prompts will cover course materials up to the point of the exam; they will emphasize synthetic understanding of course materials and will not require outside research. We estimate the exam will only take a couple of hours to complete, however, given the circumstances, we will make it available during two days and students may complete it at any time during that window.

: [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/assignments/1010459 '''Exam link (Canvas)''']

: Exam available: March 7
: Exam due: March 8

====== Community Advising assignments 1 & 2 ======

Undergraduate students in the course will also be required to complete two Community Advising assignments (CA1 and CA2, for short). For each assignment, you are invited to serve as an expert advisor to the leaders and members of an online community or crowd and to provide evidence-based insights into how to better address a specific challenge they face. 

:'''[[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Community_advising_assignments#CA1%3A_Participation_gaps_on_English_Wikipedia|Detailed information about both assignments is available here]]


'''CA1: 1500-1800 words'''
For CA1, the teaching team will select the community/crowd as well as the challenge. In elaborating your recommendations to address the challenge, we expect you to draw on sources and evidence provided as part of the course (readings, lecture, section materials, etc.). You may, but absolutely do not need to draw on additional sources.

''Update (Feb 2.): [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Community_advising_assignments#CA1%3A_Participation_gaps_on_English_Wikipedia|CA1 details have been posted]]

'''CA2: 2000-2250 words'''
For CA2, you will select your own community/crowd and challenge. We encourage you to choose a community/crowd of which you are a member/leader and where you could, even if only in theory, deliver your recommendations to other members/leaders and have some chance of seeing the recommendations debated/adopted. For CA2 we expect you to draw on sources and evidence provided as part of the course (again) as well as any additional materials you deem relevant/useful. Please note that we require you to meet with a member of the teaching team to discuss your plan and to secure written (email or chat is fine) approval of your chosen community/crowd and challenge at least two weeks before CA2 is due.

: CA1 announced: February 2
: CA1 due: February 9
: CA2 topic proposal: February 9-March 2
: CA2 due: March 16

'''Assessment rubric for CA1 and CA2'''

The teaching team will evaluate both CA1 and CA2 along the following dimensions and criteria, which overlap a great deal with Aaron's [[User:Aaronshaw/Assessment|general assessment rubric for written work]]. Keep in mind, these dimensions and criteria don't correspond to specific point values or anything like that. They also tend to escalate in terms of difficulty. An exceptional paper does all of these things exceptionally; a very good paper does all of these things well; a good paper does most of these things well; etc.

'''Clarity & style:''' Is the paper readable and clear? Is it free of errors? Is the writing logically organized and coherent? Are sources appropriately cited/documented?

'''Quality of analysis:''' Does the paper provide clear, original, and well-supported arguments and interpretation? Does it identify and analyze the challenge(s) facing the community/crowd effectively? Where possible/reasonable, does the analysis draw on relevant evidence to support its claims and recommendations?

'''Scope:''' Does the argument adapt a suitable scope given the length constraints of the assignment? Does it provide a thorough and focused analysis of the key issues at hand? Is there an appropriate balance between high-level generalities and specific details?

'''Quality of insight:''' Does the paper propose a clear strategy, design, and/or actions in response to the challenge? Do the proposed strategy, design, and/or actions seem compelling and worth adopting given the evidence presented? Do the proposed strategies, designs, and/or actions reflect a creative and sophisticated synthesis of available evidence, relevant course materials, and other resources the author has chosen to draw upon?

===== Graduate: Original research project =====
Graduate students in the course will be required to complete an original research project. This project may take the form of (1) a detailed research plan/proposal; (2) a replication/revisit of an important and influential study; (3) a completed original research manuscript (i.e., a "submission-ready" draft of a journal article or conference paper). Please note that you are also required to submit an abstract/proposal for the project and you must submit a new abstract/proposal at least two weeks before the project due date if you want to change the topic/direction substantially.

: Project abstract/proposal due: February 23
: Completed project due: March 16

==== Discussion sections ====

The center of this course will be your discussion section. Attendance and participation are mandatory. Detailed attendance and participation policies will be provided by the respective section leaders.

* Undergraduate discussion section details can be found on the [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Undergraduate_sections|Undergraduate sections page]].

Sections are meant to provide you with an opportunity to confront, challenge, and explore the major themes of each week in a safe, respectful environment. Your active participation is indispensable, so come prepared, ready to test out ideas and hypotheses. Please keep in mind that participation is about more than who speaks the most. It is also about demonstrating a willingness to think through your own and others’ ideas. Some ground rules:
* Respect others’ rights to hold opinions and beliefs different from yours. Challenge the idea, not the person.
* Listen carefully to what others are saying even when you disagree. Comments that you make (asking for clarification, sharing critiques, expanding on a point, etc.) should reflect that you have paid attention to the speaker’s comments.
* Be courteous. Don’t interrupt or engage in private conversations while others are speaking.
* Support your statements. Use evidence and provide a rationale for your points.
* Allow everyone the chance to talk. If you have spoken a lot already, try to hold back a bit; if you are hesitant to speak, look for opportunities to contribute to the discussion.

=== Grading and assessment ===

The teaching team will assign grades (usually a number between 0-10) that assess your performance of several elements of the course listed in the table below. For each element, grades start with the maximum possible value (10) and only decrease in the event of a specific failure to meet some aspect of the relevant assessment rubric (more on those below). The percentage values are weights that will be applied to calculate your overall grade for the course.

{| class="wikitable"
|-
! Course element 
! Undergraduate
! Graduate
|-
| Participation
| 20%
| 20%
|-
| Weekly assignments
| 15%
| 30%
|-
| Wikipedia assignment
| 15%
| 15%
|-
| Community Advising #1
| 10%
| NA
|-
| Community Advising #2
| 20%
| NA
|-
| Exam
| 20%
| NA
|-
| Original research project
| NA
| 35%
|}

For detailed assessment rubrics that the teaching team will use to derive grades for all assignments, please see the corresponding assignment page as well as Aaron's [[User:Aaronshaw/Assessment|general assessment page]]. Other relevant information about academic integrity policies, grade appeals (requests to regrade), and more can be found on the [[User:Aaronshaw/Classroom_policies|general course policies page]].

=== Policies ===
==== General course policies ====

[[User:Aaronshaw/Classroom_policies|General policies]] (including links to Northwestern's recommended policies) on a wide variety of topics including classroom equity, attendance, academic integrity, accommodations, late assignments, and more are provided [[User:Aaronshaw/Classroom_policies|on Aaron's class policies page]]. Below are some policy statements specific to this course and quarter.

==== COVID-19 Policies ====

Aaron's [[User:Aaronshaw/COVID_policies|COVID-19 policies page]] provides specific COVID-19 policies mandated by Northwestern University. Several additional COVID-19-related policies follow below.

==== Teaching and learning in a pandemic ====

Even beyond my [[User:Aaronshaw/COVID_policies|COVID-19 policies]], the ongoing pandemic will impact this course in various ways, some of them obvious and tangible and others harder to pin down. On the obvious and tangible front, we have things like the fact that we will begin quarter remotely and, assuming we return to campus, will still be wearing masks when we do so. These will shape our collective experience in major ways. 

On the "harder to pin down" side, even though (or maybe especially because) we've been doing this pandemic thing for a while now, many of us may experience elevated levels of exhaustion, stress, uncertainty and/or distraction. We may need to provide unexpected support to family, friends, or others in our communities. I have some personal experiences with this and I expect that many (all?) of you do too. It can be a difficult time.

It is important to acknowledge the realities of the situation and create the space to discuss and process them in the context of our class throughout the quarter. As your instructor and colleague, I commit to do my best to approach the course in an adaptive, generous, and empathetic way. I will try to be transparent and direct with you throughout—both with respect to the course material as well as the pandemic and the university's ongoing response to it. I ask that you try to extend a similar attitude towards everyone in the course. When you have questions, feedback, or concerns, please try to share them in an appropriate, empathetic way. If you require accommodations of any kind at any time (directly related to the pandemic or not), please contact me.

==== Expectations for class sessions ====

The following are some baseline expectations for our class sessions. Please feel free to ask questions, suggest changes, or raise concerns during the quarter. I welcome all input.
* All members of the class are expected to create a supportive and welcoming environment that is respectful of the conditions under which we are participating in this class.
* All members of the class are expected to take reasonable steps to create an effective teaching/learning environment for themselves and others.
Please note that these expectations apply independent of whatever modalities we use to hold the class!

===== Expectations for synchronous remote "lecture" sessions =====
And here are suggested protocols for any video/audio portions of the "lecture" portions of our class (i.e., the Wednesday meetings):
* Please mute your microphone whenever you're not speaking and learn to use [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Push-to-talk "push-to-talk"] if/when possible.
* Video is optional for students during lecture, although if you're willing/able to keep the instructors company in the video channel we always appreciate it. 
* If possible, we ask you to enable video when you want to speak (ask a question, make a comment, etc.) or are in breakout rooms.
* If you need to excuse yourself at any time and for any reason you may do so.
* Children, family, pets, roommates, and others with whom you may share your workspace are welcome to join our class as needed. Please do your best to minimize distractions and disruptions to others in the course.

===== Expectations for in-person sessions =====

Please '''wear a suitable and well-fitting face covering over your nose and mouth''' for the duration of our time in class together.

I ask everyone to come to our in-person class sessions prepared to comply with all applicable university COVID-19 policies and guidelines. We will be following Northwestern's [https://www.northwestern.edu/coronavirus-covid-19-updates/academics/instructional-spaces/index.html guidelines for instructional spaces], including the use of face coverings, consistent seating, and health monitoring using the [https://symptomtracker.northwestern.edu/ Symptom Tracker] app (either the mobile or web-based version is fine). We'll review this early in the quarter as Northwestern continues to update its policies and guidelines.

==== Syllabus revisions ====

This syllabus will be a dynamic document that will evolve throughout the quarter. Although the core expectations are fixed, the details will shift. As a result, please keep in mind the following:

# '''Assignments and readings are ''frozen'' 1 week before they are due.''' I will not add readings or assignments less than one week before they are due. If I forget to add something or fill in a "To Be Determined" less than one week before it's due, it is dropped. If you plan to read or work more than one week ahead, contact me first.
# '''Substantial changes to the syllabus or course materials will be announced.''' Please monitor your email for Canvas messages about changes. Also, whenever I make changes, these changes will be recorded in [https://wiki.communitydata.science/index.php?title=Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)&action=history  the edit history of this page] so that you can track what has changed.
# '''Changes will usually reduce/change work, only rarely augment.''' I tend to be a little over-ambitious with my syllabus content and then dial that back as I sort out what's most crucial and what can be tossed overboard.
# '''The course design may adapt throughout the quarter.''' As usual (for me at least), I may iterate and prototype course design elements rapidly along the way. To this end, I will ask you for voluntary feedback — especially toward the beginning of the quarter. Please let me know what is working and what can be improved. In the past, I have made many adjustments based on this feedback and I expect to do so again.

=== Additional resources/readings ===

Throughout the quarter, we will undoubtedly generate a long list of related topics, readings, videos, memes, etc. You can '''[[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Resources|add things to that list here]]'''

== Schedule (with all the details) ==

Please note that the date provided for each week corresponds to the Wednesday session when we all meet together. Everyone also has discussion sections

=== Week 1: Origins (01.05) ===

==== Lectures ====
# Introduction ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=97f5f819-82c9-4917-903d-ae13004c418c Part 1], [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=e379f5fb-d047-427a-bf5f-ae13004a1fb7 Part 2], and [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=67b6ff86-19d8-43e4-8744-ae13004bef9c Part 3])
# Course logistics ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=cc884085-fbd9-448c-af55-ae12014adbe5 Part 1] and [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=e6a56f3e-9047-4961-b243-ae12014c8a8e Part 2])
# Birth of the "modem world" (via Zoom, [https://northwestern.zoom.us/rec/share/EqnDoj0YNDFzaspLwdFdvcBMLc15h_qJpMYFo5UNsPWqC2WK8l1DSgepj2Avmemo.dKnttr-S8uti84re recording (includes transcription)])

;[https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides Lecture slides] (via Canvas)

==== Assignments ====
* Complete the readings/viewings below (note that graduate students should complete undergraduate+graduate readings)
* Enroll in our course Wikipedia Assignment (link and passcode distributed via Canvas)
* Complete Week 1 Wikipedia assignment exercises
* Join the course Discord server (invitation link distributed via Canvas)

===== Undergraduate =====
* John Perry Barlow. 1996. [https://www.eff.org/cyberspace-independence A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace].
* Katie Hafner. 1997. [http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/5.05/ff_well_pr.html The epic saga of The WELL]. Wired Magazine. (Long magazine article!)
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJgRHYw9-fU&list=PLgE-9Sxs2IBVgJkY-1ZMj0tIFxsJ-vOkv The BBS Documentary] (watch at least 15-20 minutes of the first video/part. Feel free to watch more if you get into it).

===== Graduate =====
* Driscoll, Kevin. [https://digitallibrary.usc.edu/asset-management/2A3BF16X9IB9 Hobbyist inter-networking and the popular Internet imaginary: Forgotten histories of networked personal computing, 1978-1998]. Doctoral Thesis, University of Southern California (Chapter 2-3; optional: skim Chapter 1).
* Turner, Fred. 2005. [http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/technology_and_culture/v046/46.3turner.html Where the counterculture met the new economy: The WELL and the origins of virtual community]. ''Technology and Culture.''

==== Additional resources (not required! optional!) ====
* Steve Jobs. 2005. [http://news.stanford.edu/news/2005/june15/jobs-061505.html Commencement Address]. Stanford University, Stanford, CA. (Note: you can watch or read this one in various places)
* Stanford 2011 symposium: [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5kQYWLtW3Y From Counterculture to Cyberculture: the Legacy of the Whole Earth Catalog].
* Margaret O'Mara. 2019 ''The Code: Silicon Valley and the Remaking of America''. Penguin Press.

=== Week 2: Definitions (01.12) ===
==== Lectures ====
# What (was|is) a ''community'' anyway? ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=44087577-4130-456f-acf0-ae19011246bb recordings])
# Crowds: Their madness and wisdom ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=44087577-4130-456f-acf0-ae19011246bb recordings])
# Defining online communities & crowds ([https://northwestern.zoom.us/rec/share/tFGVL_ThFdKr4qkOrbNJQkIf-uD4xj3an21Omg04JO8mPdG6ia_uQwauSyUOG-kn._BTPqEavNWLSlIdi zoom recording])

; [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%202 Lecture slides] (via Canvas)

==== Assignments ====
* Complete Week 2 Wikipedia assignment exercises (due Friday)
* First reading quiz (378) and discussion memos (525) this week.

===== Undergraduate readings =====
* Oldenburg, Ray. 1989. ''The great good place: Cafés, coffee shops, community centers, beauty parlors, general stores, bars, hangouts, and how they get you through the day.'' Paragon House Publishers. [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/12840997/download?download_frd=1 Chapter 1 ("The Problem of Place in America") and Chapter 2 ("The Character of Third Places")].
* Bruckman, Amy. 2006. [https://www.cc.gatech.edu/~asb/papers/conference/bruckman-community-chi06.pdf A new perspective on ‘community’ and its implications for computer-mediated communication systems]. In ''Extended Abstracts of the ACM CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems'', pp. 616-621.

===== Graduate readings =====
* Hampton, Keith. 2016. [https://www.mysocialnetwork.net/downloads/offprint/PersistentandPervasive_Hampton.pdf Persistent and pervasive community: New communication technologies and the future of community]. ''American Behavioral Scientist''.
* O’Mahony, Siobhan, Lakhani, Karim. R. 2011. [https://www.hbs.edu/ris/Publication%20Files/11-131.pdf Organizations in the shadow of communities], In Marquis, C., Lounsbury, M., Greenwood, R. (eds.), Research in the Sociology of Organizations, vol. 33: Communities and Organizations: 3–36. Bingley, UK: Emerald Group. (Link is working paper / pre-print version).

==== Additional (optional!) resources ====
* Bruckman, Amy. 2016. [https://nextbison.wordpress.com/2016/04/29/the-rheingold-test The Rheingold test].
* Kim, Amy Jo. 1998. [https://people.apache.org/~jim/NewArchitect/webtech/1998/01/kim/ Nine timeless principles for building community]. Available via ''New Architect'' magazine archives.
* Simmel, Georg. [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/12844557/download?download_frd=1 The web of group affiliations] (canvas).

=== Week 3: Participation  (01.19) ===

==== Lectures ====
# Motivating participation ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=7942198a-b4f1-4f1e-bfa7-ae1f011d2915 recordings])
# Participation inequalities
# "Too much democracy in all the wrong places"

; [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%203 Lecture slides] (via Canvas)
==== Assignments ====
===== Undergraduate =====
* Kraut & Resnick. ''Building Successful Online Communities.'' [https://kraut.hciresearch.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Kraut10-Contribution-current.pdf Encouraging contributions to online communities (Chapter 2)] (pdf from Kraut's Web site).
* Buechley, L. and Hill, B. M. 2010. [https://mako.cc/academic/buechley_hill_DIS_10.pdf LilyPad in the wild: How hardware's long tail is supporting new engineering and design communities]. Proceedings of the ACM Designing Interactive Systems (DIS) Conference.

===== Graduate =====
* van de Rijt et al. 2014. [https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1316836111 Field experiments of success-breeds-success dynamics]. Proceedings of the National Academies of Sciences (PNAS).
* Shaw, Fiers, and Hargittai. Unpublished manuscript. [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/12901599/download?download_frd=1 Participation inequality in the gig economy].
* Dunbar-Hester, Christina. 2020. Hacking diversity: The politics of inclusion in open technology cultures. ([https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/12898596/download?download_frd=1 Chapters 1, 7, 8])

===== Additional resources =====
* Kelty, Christopher, M. 2017. [https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdfplus/10.1086/688705 Too Much Democracy in All the Wrong Places: Toward a Grammar of Participation]. Current Anthropology 2017 58:S15, S77-S90 
* Kelty, C. and Erickson, S. 2018. [https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/01972243.2018.1463046 Two modes of participation: A conceptual analysis of 102 cases of Internet and social media participation from 2005–2015]. The Information Society, 34(2): 71–87.

; Additional resources about Twitch
* Clark, Taylor. 2017. [https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/11/20/how-to-get-rich-playing-video-games-online How to Get Rich Playing Video Games Online]. New Yorker, November 13, 2017.
* Hernandez, Patricia. 2018. [https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/16/17569520/twitch-streamers-zero-viewers-motivation-community The Twitch Streamers Who Spend Years Broadcasting to No One]. The Verge. July 16, 2018.
* [https://gameonaire.com/differences-between-partner-affiliate-twitch/ The Differences Between Twitch Partner and Affiliate Programs]. 2019. GameOnAire (blog). April 5, 2019.
* [https://help.twitch.tv/s/article/achievements?language=en_US. Achievements]. n.d. Twitch. Accessed January 15, 2022.
* Grayson, Nathan. 2018. [https://kotaku.com/twitch-partners-feeling-burned-after-affiliates-receive-1826810027 Twitch Partners Feeling Burned After Affiliates Receive Features That Took Them Years To Earn]. Kotaku. June 14, 2018.

=== Week 4: Newcomers (01.26) ===

==== Lectures ====
# Newcomer recruitment and socialization ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=c812ed27-6c5c-4ba4-b37b-ae270129df43 recordings])
# On the varieties of newcomer experience

;[https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%204 Lecture slides] (via Canvas)

==== Assignments ====
===== Wikipedia Assignment (all) =====
: [https://dashboard.wikiedu.org/courses/Northwestern_University/Online_communities_and_crowds_(Winter)/timeline#week-4 WikiEdu dashboard timeline for this week]
* Article topic selection complete.
* Develop draft articles in sandbox/user namespace.
* Peer review another group's article late this week.

===== Undergraduate =====
* Kraut & Resnick. ''Building Successful Online Communities'', [https://kraut.hciresearch.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/kraut10-Newcomers-current.pdf Dealing with newcomers (Chapter 5)] (pdf from Kraut's Web site).
* Charles Kiene, Andrés Monroy-Hernández, and Benjamin Mako Hill. 2016. [https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858356 Surviving an "Eternal September": How an Online Community Managed a Surge of Newcomers]. In Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '16). Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, USA, 1152–1156. https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858356

===== Graduate =====
* Corey Brian Jackson, Carsten Østerlund, Kevin Crowston, Mahboobeh Harandi, and Laura Trouille. 2020. [https://doi.org/10.1145/3392841 Shifting forms of Engagement: Volunteer Learning in Online Citizen Science]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 4, CSCW1, Article 036, 19 pages.
* Aaron Halfaker, Aniket Kittur, and John Riedl. 2011. [http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/2038558.2038585 Don't bite the newbies: How reverts affect the quantity and quality of Wikipedia work]. In Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Wikis and Open Collaboration (WikiSym '11). ACM, New York, NY, USA, 163--172.
* Casey Fiesler and Brianna Dym. 2020. [https://doi.org/10.1145/3392847 Moving Across Lands: Online Platform Migration in Fandom Communities]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 4, CSCW1, Article 042 (May 2020), 25 pages. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1145/3392847

==== Additional resources ====
* [https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/wiki/posting_guidelines Posting Guidelines], r/nosleep Wiki. Accessed January 25, 2022.
* Susan L. Bryant, Andrea Forte, and Amy Bruckman. 2005. [https://doi.org/10.1145/1099203.1099205 Becoming Wikipedian: transformation of participation in a collaborative online encyclopedia]. In Proceedings of the 2005 international ACM SIGGROUP conference on Supporting group work (GROUP '05).
* Preece, Jennifer and Schneiderman, Ben. 2009. [https://aisel.aisnet.org/thci/vol1/iss1/5/ The reader-to-leader framework: Motivating technology-mediated social participation]. ''AIS Transaction on Human-Computer Interaction.''
* Seering et al. 2020. [https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3313831.3376151 Proximate social factors in first-time contribution to online communities]. CHI.
* Sneha Narayan, Jake Orlowitz, Jonathan Morgan, Benjamin Mako Hill, and Aaron Shaw. 2017. [https://doi.org/10.1145/2998181.2998307 The Wikipedia Adventure: Field Evaluation of an Interactive Tutorial for New Users]. In Proceedings of the 2017 ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW '17).
* Van Maanen, John. 1978. [https://doi.org/10.1016/0090-2616(78)90032-3 People processing: Strategies of organizational socialization], Organizational Dynamics, (7)1. 19-36.

=== Week 5: Identity (02.02) ===

==== Lectures ====
# Identity: The presentation of online self ([https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=22ae884d-10ca-49a9-9ac9-ae2e01554e48 recordings])
# Privacy, context, and disclosure
# Anonymity: Threat or menace?

;[https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%205 Lecture slides] (via Canvas)

==== Assignments ====
===== Community Advising Assignment #1 =====
* [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Community_advising_assignments#CA1%3A_Participation_gaps_on_English_Wikipedia|Challenge and setting details]] distributed on 2/2. [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/assignments/1004974 Completed assignment due 2/9].

===== Wikipedia Assignment (all) =====
: [https://dashboard.wikiedu.org/courses/Northwestern_University/Online_communities_and_crowds_(Winter)/timeline#week-5 WikiEdu dashboard timeline for this week]
* Expand draft articles
* Complete peer review of another group's article.

===== Undergraduate =====
* Judith Donath. 1998. [http://judithdonath.net/papers/Donath/IdentityDeception/IdentityDeception.pdf Identity and deception in the virtual community]. In Kollock, P. and Smith, M. (eds). ''Communities in Cyberspace''. London: Routledge. pp. 37-68.
* Kishonna L. Gray. 2012. [https://doi.org/10.1080/1369118X.2011.642401 Intersecting oppressions and online communities]. Information, Communication & Society, 15:3, 411-428, DOI: 10.1080/1369118X.2011.642401

===== Graduate =====
* Acquisti, Alessandro, Laura Brandimarte, and George Loewenstein. [https://www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/science.aaa1465 Privacy and human behavior in the age of information]. Science 347.6221 (2015): 509-514.
* Hill, Benjamin Mako, and Aaron Shaw. [https://mako.cc/academic/hill_shaw-hidden_costs_of_requiring_accounts-PREPRINT.pdf The Hidden Costs of Requiring Accounts: Quasi-Experimental Evidence From Peer Production]. Communication Research (2020): 0093650220910345.
* <del>Nazanin Andalibi, Margaret E. Morris, and Andrea Forte. 2018. [https://doi.org/10.1145/3274288 Testing Waters, Sending Clues: Indirect Disclosures of Socially Stigmatized Experiences on Social Media]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 2, CSCW, Article 19 (November 2018), 23 pages. https://doi.org/10.1145/3274288<del>
* (''optional'') Nazanin Andalibi, Oliver L. Haimson, Munmun De Choudhury, and Andrea Forte. 2016. Understanding Social Media Disclosures of Sexual Abuse Through the Lenses of Support Seeking and Anonymity. In Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '16). Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, USA, 3906–3918. https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858096

==== Additional resources ====
* Bernstein, M., Monroy-Hernández, A., Harry, D., André, P., Panovich, K., & Vargas, G. 2011. [https://ojs.aaai.org/index.php/ICWSM/article/view/14134 4chan and /b/: An Analysis of Anonymity and Ephemerality in a Large Online Community]. Proceedings of the International AAAI Conference on Web and Social Media, 5(1), 50-57.
* Dibbell, J. (1993, Dec 23). [http://www.juliandibbell.com/texts/bungle_vv.html A rape in cyberspace: How an evil clown, a Haitian trickster spirit, two wizards, and a cast of dozens turned a database into a society]. The Village Voice. 
* Goffman, Erving. 1959. ''The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life.''
*  K. L. Gray. 2012. [https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13614568.2012.746740 Deviant bodies, stigmatized identities, and racist acts: examining the experiences of African-American gamers in Xbox Live], New Review of Hypermedia and Multimedia, 18:4, 261-276, https://10.1080/13614568.2012.746740

=== Week 6: Governance (02.09) ===

==== Lectures ====
# Governing the digital commons: A crude and brief synthesis
# Governance of and by (and within?) platforms
# Order from chaos? Governance in autonomous communities

: '''[https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=6115fc48-9698-40d4-9eb5-ae350029f168 Lecture recordings]''' (Panopto) and '''[https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%206 lecture slides]''' (Canvas)

: '''Guest speaker in class Wed.:''' Molly de Blanc (Debian Project, Gnome Project, Community Data Science Collective, NYU, and more)

==== Assignments ====
===== Community Advising Assignment #1 =====
* [[Online_Communities_and_Crowds_(Winter_2022)/Community_advising_assignments#CA1%3A_Participation_gaps_on_English_Wikipedia|CA1 details and instructions]]
* [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/assignments/1004974 Completed assignment due 2/9].

===== Wikipedia Assignment (all) =====
: [https://dashboard.wikiedu.org/courses/Northwestern_University/Online_communities_and_crowds_(Winter)/timeline#week-6 WikiEdu dashboard timeline for this week]

* Move article drafts into "main namespace."
* Revise articles in response to peer feedback.

===== Undergraduate =====
* Kiesler, S, Kittur, A., Kraut, R., & Resnick, P. 2012. [https://kraut.hciresearch.info/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/kiesler10-Regulation-current.pdf Regulating behavior in online communities] in Kraut, R. and Resnick, P. ''Building Successful Online Communities'' (Chapter 4).
* Gillespie, Tarleton. 2018. [https://culturedigitally.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Gillespie-Governance-ofby-Platforms-PREPRINT.pdf Governance of and by platforms]. In Sage Handbook of Social Media, Jean Burgess,Thomas Poell, and Alice Marwick (eds).
* Read and compare/contrast the [https://wiki.gnome.org/action/show/Foundation/CodeOfConduct GNOME Code of Conduct] with the [https://ubuntu.com/community/code-of-conduct Ubuntu Code of Conduct v2.0].
* ''Optional'' (because it was added late): [https://www.debian.org/code_of_conduct Debian project Code of Conduct].

===== Graduate =====

* Manoel Horta Ribeiro, Shagun Jhaver, Savvas Zannettou, Jeremy Blackburn, Gianluca Stringhini, Emiliano De Cristofaro, and Robert West. 2021. [https://dlab.epfl.ch/people/west/pub/HortaRibeiro-Jhaver-Zannettou-Blackburn-DeCristofaro-Stringhini-West_CSCW-21.pdf Do Platform Migrations Compromise Content Moderation? Evidence from r/The_Donald and r/Incels]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 5, CSCW2, Article 316 (October 2021), 24 pages. https://doi.org/10.1145/3476057
* Massa, F. G., & O’Mahony, S. 2021. [https://doi.org/10.1177%2F00018392211008880 Order from Chaos: How Networked Activists Self-Organize by Creating a Participation Architecture]. Administrative Science Quarterly. doi:10.1177/00018392211008880.
* Schneider, Nathan. 2021. [https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444820986553 Admins, Mods, and Benevolent Dictators for Life: The Implicit Feudalism of Online Communities]. New Media & Society.

==== Additional resources ====
* Aurora, Valerie and Gardiner, Mary. 2019. [https://frameshiftconsulting.com/resources/code-of-conduct-book/ How to respond to code of conduct reports]. Frameshift Consulting. 
* Hampton, Rachelle. 2019. [https://slate.com/technology/2019/04/black-feminists-alt-right-twitter-gamergate.html The black feminists who saw the alt-right coming]. Slate.
* Ilori, Tomiwa. 2020. [https://slate.com/technology/2020/08/social-media-content-moderation-african-nations.html Content moderation is particularly hard in African countries]. Slate.
* Massachi, Saher. 2021. [https://www.technologyreview.com/2021/12/20/1042709/how-to-save-social-media-treat-it-like-a-city/ How to save our social media by treating it like a city]. MIT Technology Review.

=== Week 7: Quality (02.16) ===

==== Lectures ====
# How do they do it? Community production dynamics
# Social production, social failures

: [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=0bc61fc9-2572-41c0-818b-ae3c0164464e '''Lecture recordings'''] (panopto) and [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/13185232/download?download_frd=1 '''slides'''] (canvas)

==== Assignments ====
===== Wikipedia Assignment (all) =====
* Articles revised and published in main namespace.
* [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/assignments/1004976 Wikipedia assignment reflection essay due 2/18].

===== Undergraduate =====
* Benkler, Yochai. 2006. [https://cyber.harvard.edu/wealth_of_networks/Download_PDFs_of_the_book The Wealth of Networks]. Yale University Press. Ch. 2 excerpt (pp. 29-34) & Ch. 3 (all).
* Casey Fiesler, Shannon Morrison, and Amy S. Bruckman. 2016. [https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858409 An Archive of Their Own: A Case Study of Feminist HCI and Values in Design]. In Proceedings of the 2016 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '16). https://doi.org/10.1145/2858036.2858409

===== Graduate =====
* Ashley Colley, Jacob Thebault-Spieker, Allen Yilun Lin, Donald Degraen, Benjamin Fischman, Jonna Häkkilä, Kate Kuehl, Valentina Nisi, Nuno Jardim Nunes, Nina Wenig, Dirk Wenig, Brent Hecht, and Johannes Schöning. 2017. [https://doi.org/10.1145/3025453.3025495 The Geography of Pokémon GO: Beneficial and Problematic Effects on Places and Movement]. In Proceedings of the 2017 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI '17). https://doi.org/10.1145/3025453.3025495
* Kate Starbird, Ahmer Arif, and Tom Wilson. 2019. [https://doi.org/10.1145/3359229 Disinformation as Collaborative Work: Surfacing the Participatory Nature of Strategic Information Operations]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 3, CSCW, Article 127 (November 2019). https://doi.org/10.1145/3359229

==== Additional resources ====
* King, Gary, Jennifer Pan, and Margaret E. Roberts. (2017). [https://gking.harvard.edu/files/gking/files/how_the_chinese_government_fabricates_social_media_posts_for_strategic_distraction_not_engaged_argument.pdf How the Chinese government fabricates social media posts for strategic distraction, not engaged argument]. American Political Science Review 111, no. 3: 484-501.
* Stallman, R. (1984). [https://www.gnu.org/gnu/manifesto.html The GNU manifesto].
* Stallman, R. (1989). [https://gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.html The GNU general public license, version 1]. 
* von Hippel, E. (2012). [http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=cKcAcm5NDOI The Paradigm Shift from Producer to User Innovation] (video lecture).
* von Hippel, E. (2012). [http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=odj5VnTI490 Users Working Together in Communities are Powerful Innovators] (video lecture).
* von Hippel, E. (2005). [http://web.mit.edu/evhippel/www/democ1.htm Democratizing innovation]. MIT Press.

=== Week 8: Profit (02.23) ===

==== Lectures ====
# A withering critique of contemporary information capitalism
# Whither alternatives? 

: [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=6a62de8f-8947-4b93-a58d-ae44011431a5 Lecture recording (panopto)] and [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/files/folder/lecture%20slides/Week%208 slides (canvas)]
==== Assignments ====
===== Undergraduate =====
* Mary Gray and Siddharth Suri. 2019. Ghost Work. Read Introduction, Chs 1, 3, and 6 (Other chapters and Conclusion optional). (Available via [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/13203473/download?download_frd=1 via Canvas] or [https://archive.org/details/mary-l.-gray-siddharth-suri-ghost-work-how-to-stop-silicon-valley-from-building- the Internet Archive])

===== Graduate =====
* Abhishek Nagaraj and Henning Piezunka. 2020 (unpublished ms). [https://abhishekn.com/files/openstreetmap_google_feb2020.pdf How Competition Affects Contributions to Open Source Platforms: Evidence from OpenStreetMap and Google Maps].
* Nathan Schneider. 2018. [https://doi.org/10.1177/0038026118758533 An internet of ownership: Democratic design for the online economy]. The Sociological Review 66, no. 2 (March 2018): 320–40. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038026118758533

==== Additional resources ====
* Davis, Gerald F., and Aseem Sinha. [https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/2631787721995198 Varieties of Uberization: How technology and institutions change the organization (s) of late capitalism]. Organization Theory 2, no. 1 (2021): 2631787721995198.
* Juliet B. Schor and Manuel Vallas. 2020. The sharing economy: Rhetoric and reality. Annual Review of Sociology. 
* Juliet B. Schor. 2020. After the gig: How the sharing economy got hijacked and how to win it back. University of California Press.
* Shoshanna Zuboff. 2019. The Age of Surveillance Capitalism.

=== Week 9: AI (03.02) ===

==== Lectures ====
# The ubiquity of bots, algorithms, and machine intelligence in online communities
# FATE and other horizons of AI

: [https://northwestern.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx?folderID=74ee14bc-306a-457a-a1ae-ae4401143753 Lecture recordings] (Panopto) and [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/files/13329976/download?download_frd=1 slides] (canvas).
==== Assignments ====
===== Undergraduate =====
* Massanari, Adrienne. "[https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1461444815608807 #Gamergate and The Fappening: How Reddit’s algorithm, governance, and culture support toxic technocultures]." New media & society 19, no. 3 (2017): 329-346.
* Simpson, Ellen and Bryan Semaan. 2021. [https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3432951 For You, or For"You"? Everyday LGBTQ+ Encounters with TikTok]. Proc. ACM Hum.-Comput. Interact. 4, CSCW3, Article 252 (December 2020), 34 pages. DOI:https://doi.org/10.1145/3432951

===== Graduate =====
* Michael Ann DeVito. 2021. Adaptive Folk Theorization as a Path to Algorithmic Literacy on Changing Platforms. In Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, Vol. 5, CSCW2, Article 339 (October 2021), 35 pages, [https://doi.org/10.1145/3476080 https://doi.org/10.1145/3476080].
* Geiger, R. Stuart (2014). Bots, bespoke, code and the materiality of software platforms. Information, Communication & Society. DOI:10.1080/1369118X.2013.873069 ([https://escholarship.org/content/qt6xc0m98k/qt6xc0m98k.pdf preprint version])

==== Additional resources ====

=== Week 10: The Future (03.09) ===

==== Lectures ====
# The future of online communities & crowds

==== Assignments ====
===== Undergraduate =====
* [https://canvas.northwestern.edu/courses/160351/assignments/1010459 Take-home exam (distributed 3/7, due 3/8)]

==== Additional resources ====

== Acknowledgments and Credits ==

This course design and syllabus builds from prior iterations as well as similar/adjacent courses offered by Joseph Reagle (Northeastern University); Benjamin Mako Hill (University of Washington); Nathan TeBlunthuis (Northwestern), Casey Fiesler (University of Colorado at Boulder); Amy Bruckman (Georgia Institute of Technology); Sarita Yardi Schoenbeck (University of Michigan); Nazanin Andalibi (University of Michigan); and Nicole Ellison (University of Michigan). It has also been shaped by input from past students in the course and past teaching assistants (Sneha Narayan and Jeremy Foote) as well as current participants. Some of the language and policies were co-authored with Daniel Immerwahr (Northwestern).